Ahead of the Autumn Budget on 22 November, Tom Hopkins and Richard Hoskins write an open letter to Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond on the subject of encouraging investment in growth businesses.

Dear Chancellor,

You, above all people, will be aware that the headlines are dominated by all things Brexit and the clouds of uncertainty that surround all of us in the UK.

No doubt you are also aware that, less prominently, there has been quite a lot in the press recently about the subject of tax-efficient investing – namely the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) and venture capital trusts (VCTs).

These press articles are a result of the Patient Capital Review, which you launched in August to review the funding of growth businesses, and the heightened speculation that EIS and VCT rules and limits are under your microscope.

This speculation has caused considerable consternation among those of us who are immersed in this world. Indeed, these concerns were highlighted by a recent letter to the Sunday Times signed by such luminaries as Lord Howard Flight, Lord David Blunkett and Lord Michael Grade.

So, as you put the finishing touches to your Budget, here are some hopefully helpful suggestions should you be deliberating on this powerful and economically positive sector.

In our view over-tinkering in this field risks compromising the future growth and prosperity of a post-Brexit Britain.

First, growth investing is a hugely positive thing for UK plc so please do not meddle too much with the UK’s venture capital schemes. We agree that tweaks are required to ensure more capital is finding its way to growth businesses, but introduce too much change and you risk paralysing or marginalising this important source of capital.

Many on the left, including Jeremy Corbyn, might view these as ‘tax breaks for the rich’ but you know better. VCTs and EIS have been around for more than 20 years and – along with business investment relief, social investment tax relief and seed EIS – do an important job building and nurturing UK plc, especially given the lack of UK institutional capital in venture capital.

And it costs HM Treasury nothing – in fact, the sector will be a net contributor in this coming tax year, given the return growth investing produces via National Insurance, PAYE, VAT and so on.

Second, given the lack of UK institutional capital – notably from pension funds – investing in venture capital, and hence growth businesses, may we suggest you look at ways of offering corporates incentives to invest in UK growth businesses?

Corporate venturing is, happily, on the rise as older established firms look for ways to change operating models and identify potential acquisitions early in a rapidly changing business environment. Corporate venturing is far more commonplace in the US, though, and the UK should look at the success of the various corporate incentives there.

Indeed, the UK did have a corporate venturing scheme that offered a corporation tax break for investing in EIS and VCT-type qualifying businesses but it was abolished by the Labour Government before it really got going. Given the current entrepreneurial environment and lock of scale-up capital, now could be the time to bring it back.

To read the full letter, click here.

Source: Professional Adviser



020 7071 3945


Throughout our site you will find links to external websites. Although we make every effort to ensure these links are accurate, up to date and relevant, we cannot take responsibility for pages maintained by external providers.